The main focus of advertising is to
influence consumers’ perceptions of the brand, but it is suggested advertising
can also influence children’s perceptions of themselves (Gunter, Oates and
Blades, 2005; and Marshall, 2010). Marketers use role models and attractive
lifestyles within their adverts to influence children to buy their products
(Gunter et al, 2005). Within the seminar the issue of adverts producing ‘demeaning
stereotypes’ was discussed, these stereotypes, which are often used in
advertisements, can be harmful. They can result in children developing negative
perceptions of themselves, resulting in the idea that they must conform to the ideals
of society (Gunter et al, 2005).
Children are being increasingly
influenced by commercialism and the development of consumer culture and
technology has led to children encountering advertisements more often, at a
much younger age (Marshall, 2010). Marketers’ now have an increased interest in
children as consumers, mostly due to them having purchasing power and influence
products for themselves (Ekström, 2010; and Gunter et al, 2005). So perhaps
children should be viewed as consumers. In contrast, it can be argued that
advertising has little effect on children, instead social fashions and peer
pressure may be the most important factors in creating the desire to buy
products (Proctor and Richards, 2002; and Gunter et al, 2005). Advertisements
aimed at children generally use popular characters from children’s programs. As
a result, it may be difficult for children to distinguish between advertisements
and programs and therefore children do not understand that what they are
watching is attempting to persuade them to buy products. Instead, they may be subconscious
consumers (Gunter et al, 2005).
Children are thought to be particularly
vulnerable to advertising as they know less about marketers’ intent compared to
the understanding developed by adulthood (Oates, Blades, Gunter and Don, 2003;
and Gunter et al, 2005). Bowen (2000) contradicts this, claiming that very
young children, even from the age of three, have some understanding of
particular aspects of marketing. Nevertheless, children’s recognition of
advertisements is not the same as understanding their persuasive purpose
(Gunter et al, 2005). The age of understanding has been debated, but it is
clear it may be possible to develop understanding sooner when supported by
explicit teaching in the primary years (Gunter et al, 2005). Some researchers
suggest the most effective way to help children understand advertising is
through their parents (Furnham, 2000). Though, relying on parents alone can be
limited. Not all parents may have the appropriate knowledge to teach children and
assess their levels of understanding (Gunter et al, 2005). Another way to increase
children’s understanding is through school education; encouraging children to
learn the nature of marketing. Teachers will have to take into account the ideas
discussed previously when teaching. An issue with the curriculum means that
time spent on topics such as advertising may be limited so teachers will also have
to take this into account when planning and perhaps teach advertising alongside
other areas, such as persuasive texts (Gunter et al, 2005; Burrell and Beard,
2010; and DfE, 2013).
Bibliography:
Bowen, M.
(2000), ‘Kids Culture’, International
Journal of Advertising and Marketing to Children. 2 (1) pp 19-23.
Burrell, A. and Beard, R. (2010). Children's
advertisement writing. Literacy. 44
(2) pp 83 - 90.
DfE. (2013) The National Curriculum. In Scholastic (Ed.) The National
Curriculum in England: Handbook for Primary Teachers Key stages 1 & 2. Oxfordshire.
Scholastic.
Ekström, K.
(2010) Consumer Socialization in Families. In: Marshall, D (ed.) Understanding Children as Consumers. London:
SAGE Publications.
Furnham, A. (2000): Children and Advertising: The
Allegations and the Evidence: Social Affairs Unit.
Gunter, B. Oates, C. and Blades, M. (2005). Advertising to Children on TV. New Jersey: Laurence Erlbaum Associates.
Marshall,
D (2010) Understanding Children as
Consumers. London: SAGE Publications.
Oates, C.,
Blades, M., Gunter, B., and Don, J. (2003) ‘Childrens Understanding of
Television advertising: a Qualitative Approach’, Journal of Marketing Communications. 9 (2) pp 59-71.
Proctor, J. and Richards, M. (2002) ‘Word-of-Mouth Marketing:
Beyond Pester Power’, International Journal
of Advertising and Marketing to Children, 3 (3) pp 3-12.
Here is a useful website, which I came across when researching
this blog task. It has free teaching resources to help children think critically
about advertising in the primary classroom:
I agree with the point you raise about social fashion and peer pressure playing influential roles on the desire to buy a product. Although the purpose of adverts is to increase purchases of a product (Gunter, Oates and Blades, 2005), it can be argued that 'social identity' plays a significant role in pressuring young people to buy the latest product. This is because if children have the 'latest craze' then they immediately gain a status within their social group. I have further discussed this point in my blog stating that children are often 'brand bullied' because of this, therefore I think it is important to educate children about the persuasive nature of adverts.
ReplyDeleteI am surprised to learn that children as young as three demonstrate some understanding of particular aspects of marketing (Bowen, 2000) as Pachard (1957) found that children are predominantly passive while advertisers channel their thinking habits and bypass their conscious awareness so that they believe adverts to tell the truth. In this way, the boundaries between information, entertainment and advertisement are increasingly blurred, in order to mask media’s real intent, which through cross selling, licensed merchandising and product placement is really to sell its own brand (Kenway & Bullen, 2001).
ReplyDelete